Acts2.XYZ: New Reality. Real Change.
How To Evaluate Church Leaders - Imagine Your Life Depends on It (Because it Does)
March 29, 2023
Members of the church, now more than at any time, need to have clear ways to discern proper leadership. Without it, there's very little oversight into who becomes a leader, paid or volunter, within a church. Failures can be immediately dramatic. But more likely, there is the "Leaven Effect": the slow, at first imperceptible, erosion of the Gospel. Yet, why is the risk high? It's very easy to accept on faith decisions made by the leadership as "annointings." But in the same way that companies have boards of directors that turn the other way because they have been appointed by the CEO, churches can lack accountability because a clear vector for qualification is missing. This is how wolves enter leadership. Most people think wolves are easily discernible for overtly bad behavior. But Jesus doesn't take that view. In fact, he believes they can be very difficult to detect. As Scriptural literacy continues to fall within the church, evasion, including self-deception by the well-intended, is easy. Meaning: a wolf may not even know he is one due to self-deception and prideful Scriptural illiteracy.
For references to the Scripture, check out the essay here: https://eldership.xyz/how-to-evaluate-church-leaders-imagine-your-life-depends-on-it-because-it-does/

Members of the church, now more than at any time, need to have clear ways to discern proper leadership.

Without it, there's very little oversight into who becomes a leader, paid or volunter, within a church.

Failures can be immediately dramatic. But more likely, there is the "Leaven Effect": the slow, at first imperceptible, erosion of the Gospel.

Yet, why is the risk high?

It's very easy to accept on faith decisions made by the leadership as "annointings." But in the same way that companies have boards of directors that turn the other way because they have been appointed by the CEO, churches can lack accountability because a clear vector for qualification is missing.

This is how wolves enter leadership.

Most people think wolves are easily discernible for overtly bad behavior.

But Jesus doesn't take that view. In fact, he believes they can be very difficult to detect.

As Scriptural literacy continues to fall within the church, evasion, including self-deception by the well-intended, is easy. Meaning: a wolf may not even know he is one due to self-deception and prideful Scriptural illiteracy.

The mistake is that if the person is "nice" or appears to have good intentions, proper "behavior" -- that person couldn't be vicious.

But we take the Scripture incorrectly. We "imagine" that the person's conscious intent must be evil and vicious; therefore they are wolves. When we can't believe that about someone, we assume the outward "harmless sheep" must be capable and a Christ follower.

But the point of the Scripture is that it is not easy to detect. Exterior behavior can cover the heart; and in fact, it is those with the proper outward behavior that can pose the greatest threats as Jesus warns.

Who are often great candidates on the outside, but Jesus warns that those indicators aren't really right.

They include longevity at the church and knows the procedures[1], pray publicly[2], talk about generous giving[3], and abide in the visible behaviors of the church[4].

Anyone who is part of a church who wants to know what is best for your church must pay heed.

Once someone enters into an expectation of spiritual authority but aren't truly ambassadors of Christ will spread their perspective like yeast. The modern version is, once the toothpaste is squeezed out, you can't put it back.[5]

What are the bare minimum?

If we make the bar too high, it can become a bit legalistic. But a hand-wavy bar and an expectation of reputation is too loose.

Here are the five minimum viable requirements:

  1. Sound Teaching. Graceful Refutation.
  2. Expression of the Spiritual Gifts from Ephesians
  3. History of Fruitful Discipleship
  4. Right Relationship with Money
  5. A Life which Demonstrates Christ's Work in Words and Deeds

About Acts2.XYZ and Jonah Jeremiah:

Acts2.XYZ is about Real Change. New Reality.

We focus on leadership, Christian men, marriage, faith in the workplace, and innovation in the church.

Check us out at https://acts2.xyz